Tuesday, January 21, 2014

Richard Sherman versus Phil Robertson: Which is it America?

Social media, please make up your mind.

Is it okay for public figures to speak frankly and share what they believe or not????

First you freak out that poor Phil Robertson has been attacked by those gay loving liberals just for being honest about his feelings.

Then you freak out that Richard Sherman had the poor taste to smack talk a fellow NFL player following a pivotal NFC playoff game.

Before you start screaming, I get it. You think Phil’s “first amendment rights were violated.” Let’s pause while I chuckle.

Last time I checked he’s still employed, still adding millions to his net worth, and the Duck Dynasty writers are still scripting prayers into the show’s endings.

Wait, what’s that? You didn’t realize Duck Dynasty is scripted? Not to burst your bubble, but it’s scripted and the Duck Dynasty boys are second cousins to actors. What’s that? You didn’t realize that these boys used to have short hair, clean shaven faces, and suburban looking family beach photos? Hey, conservative America wants beards, long hair, camo, and prayer. Duck Dynasty provides a healthy dose of all four.

Duck Dynasty also pays Mr. Robertson and his clan a healthy paycheck, adding to their already massive bank accounts. Suffice it to say I don’t believe poor Mr. Robertson really needed the “Save Phil” campaign to survive his controversial views.

I have to admit surprise at the level of public naivete associated with these reality televisions shows.

I’m also surprised at the level of outrage over Mr. Sherman’s comments by the same supporters of Mr. Robertson.

Let me get this straight. Mr. Sherman is “a worthless piece of thug trash”, “punk”, "arrogant ass”, “asshole” and “ignorant thug”…among others. These are just quotes from actual people I know on Facebook. Want to read some more interesting descriptions? Just check out all of the comments at the end of some of the news articles.

What fascinates me is sitting back and observing what is truly offensive to people.

An irrational obsession with the private bedroom behavior of consensual adults and an inability to refrain from talking about it like a fourteen year old boy in the locker room is slightly offensive to some of us.

It appears, as well, that boasting after defeating an opponent who discounted a man’s professional ability is also slightly offensive. What leaves me shaking my head is that it was following a violent and physically aggressive sport, one that is leaving players short of being vegetables because of brain damage.

So let me get this straight.

We like to see grown men beating the crap out of each other on a grass field. We like to hear the grunts and sounds of pads violently connecting as NFL players tackle and drag each other to the ground. We love the gladiator type feel of massive arenas where (often intoxicated) fans can scream and yell passionately at players, hoping they destroy each other and caring very little about the now documented evidence of long term brain injuries that often result from our entertainment.

But we don’t want to hear any evidence of the mind set these players must possess in order to be warriors. We like the foul language and offensive words oft used by even the most beloved and golden boys of the NFL (see Tom Brady, to include chin dimple and blazing smile) to be kept on the sideline and out of the media spotlight. For the record, Mr. Sherman didn't curse.

We can stick a mic in the face of a sweaty, still panting athlete after one of the biggest plays of his career and immediately condemn him as a “thug” because he boasts that he’s the best at his position and that the person who said he wasn’t is wrong.

Yet when an actor, while representing his employer’s trademark, is interviewed we seem to have no problem with him referencing sexual acts and human orifices? As long as the comments are demeaning to an entire population of people whose sexual orientation differs from yours, then America has no problem with this appalling obsession with human sexual acts being talked about publicly and bandied about as a joke?

The football player is an “arrogant ass”. The reality tv star actor is a “hero”.

God bless America, eh?

3 comments:

  1. These days, "freedom of speech" seems to have different meanings, depending on one's interpretation. I view it as a two-way street...someone can make a comment and other voices can rebuttal, and back and forth. Some voices don't like others commenting on challenging them, which isn't free speech. If someone is going to make a comment, especially if they have celebrity and able to speak on a national or global scale, they should be thick-skinned and prepared for harsh criticism. The right to free speech is not confined to the originator of the conversation. It is universal.

    Having said all that, I don't see any parallel's to comments (and backlash) by Phil Robertson and Richard Sherman. Phil Robertson's comments are repulsive, but A&E knew this and didn't "protect" their investment. He made comments in a publication that had nothing to do with the show, however, they could have taken preventive measures to assist him with a PR representative to present his opinions. He didn't have to say all the things he was quoted in the article, and a publicist to coach their stars who obviously need a filter, would have prevented this embarrassment for them. A&E should learn from this and be more on top of it in the future.

    As for Richard Sherman, his comments weren't discriminatory or unethical. His comments were unprofessional and undignified. I also think fans and commentators were embarrassed for him, as Michael Crabtree is still recovering from a torn achille's tendon last summer and over the past two seasons (minus this injured season) averaged about 80 catches and 1,000 yards while helping his team to two consecutive NFC Championship Games and the Super Bowl. If that is "mediocre" in the NFL, where do all the other receivers not named Calvin Johnson or A.J. Green rank? He insulted the overwhelming number of receivers in the game, which means he has a huge bullseye on his chest in the Super Bowl and next season. No excuses if he or his fellow DB's get burned, so we'll see what happens. Most negative responses to his comments are also due to his failure to acknowledge his teammates. To only talk about how HE won the game, kinda rubs fans and commentator's the wrong way. He made himself a villian and is surprised that he has been portrayed that way? He needs a reality check. He will find humility at some point, as someone out there has his number, no matter how great he thinks he is. I think he is currently the best in the game, but that could change next during the next game or next season. Maybe he lives up to the hype...who knows. I think his teammates could do without opponents having bulletin board material and extra motivation to humiliate them.

    All Americans have freedom of speech, but so do critics. If you don't want the criticism, understand your audience and if you think the risk is worth the potential backlash, take your chances. Just be willing to live with the consequences.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks for the response Gary! We had a nice discussion on Facebook about this. I was more perplexed by the number of people I know who were so defensive of Robertson and yet so angry with Sherman. Made very little sense to me....but, then again, many things people do make little sense to me. At the end of the day you are correct...each of us has control over one thing - ourselves. And freedom of speech does work both ways. Will be interesting to see how Sherman's teammates respond to his "one man show". Maybe they know him better than we do. Certainly, it will be a long two weeks leading up to the Super Bowl, eh? God bless and thanks again!!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Marlys, I absolutely agree with you about things people do not making sense. I am very frustrated with the lack of critical thinking and old-fashioned common sense. I think Sherman's teammates will use the negative response to his comments (including the awful comments of "thug") to rally around him and it won't hurt them on the field. There lack of Super Bowl experience at the player and coaching levels, might. The next two weeks will be a distraction from the Super Bowl, so I will find much of it boring...so I will be watching my Super Bowl History collection and reminisce about the good ol' days! God bless you too, Marlys, and keep the stories coming! I really enjoy reading your journal, as I always learn something new...about the world we live in, and you! Ha!

    ReplyDelete